I hate Captain Underpants

I hate Captain Underpants.

For those of you who aren’t familiar with it, Captain Underpants is a book series that is widely popular among school-aged children.  There are 10 books in the series, and it will soon be made into an animated movie.  The Captain Underpants series details the adventures of Harold and George, two irreverent 4th graders who write comic books, play pranks, and battle mean classmates and teachers.  It is at times funny and creative, and deals with issues that school-aged children can relate to (e.g., bullies, mean teachers).  It is also full of potty humor, which undoubtedly increases its appeal for young boys.  But this is not why I hate the book series.  And why am I writing about a book series in my media blog?  Let me explain….

I haven’t read all of the books, but last night I was reading one of them with Sparky.  In the 9th book in the series, Captain Underpants and the Terrifying Re-Turn of Tippy Tinkletrousers, technology plays a central role in the antics of Harold and George.  In the story, Harold and George seek revenge on the school bully, Kipper, by carrying out a variety of pranks on Kipper and his friends.  For example, they send Kipper’s friends embarrassing texts that appear to have been sent from Kipper’s phone:

cu2

Later in the story, George and Harold trick Kipper and his friends into eating spicy pizza and then use their cell phones to videotape what happens next.  To ensure maximum humiliation of the bullies, they post the video online:

cu1

After reading this book with Sparky (who like many first grade boys, loves the books), I talked to him about George and Harold’s actions.  He said, “Oh, its okay Mom.  Kipper and his friends are bullies.”  We then discussed whether George and Harold’s behaviors were justified, given that Kipper was a bully. Fortunately, Sparky came to the conclusion of “no”.   But what about the children whose parents don’t have this discussion with them?  What messages are those children learning about “justifiable” harm to others?  In addition, what are children learning from this book about how to use technology to hurt others?  My 6-year-old has never touched a cell phone, but now has lots of creative ideas of how one might potentially use a cell phone to hurt others.  And according to the book, doing these things is hilarious and entertaining.

George and Harold were engaging in cyberbullying, which is the use of electronic technology to repeatedly harm others, either physically, socially, or psychologically.  Depending on the age of respondents and how it is defined, surveys indicate that 20-40% of youth have been the victims of cyberbullying.  You don’t have to be a developmental psychologist to know that cyberbullying is a serious problem among youth today. There has been substantial national media coverage of a variety of cyberbullying incidents over the past few years- most of us are familiar with the well-publicized cases that ended in tragedy, such as suicides.  Most recently, there was a horrific rape of a teenage girl in Steubenville, Ohio, in which the teenage rapists disseminated texts, photos, and a video of the incident online.  In the aftermath of the rape, the victim has continued to experience harassment through social media.  We are always shocked when youth commit a crime such as rape, but the posting of the video is one of the main factors that has garnered this particular case so much attention.  “Who would think to do such a thing?”, people gasp?  Hmmm.  I would suggest that if you teach young boys that it is funny to dehumanize others (be it bullies or women) and use technology to humiliate them, this is how we end up here as a society.  Am I saying that reading Captain Underpants causes children to grow up to become rapists and cyberbullies?  Of course not.  But I do find it deeply disturbing that children, who should be learning about respectful and responsible use of technology, are getting a very different message from this book series.  I do think there is a connection between the perpetuation of these messages (e.g., cyberbullying can be justifiable and is funny) and the ever-increasing tendency for youth perpetrators of bullying and violence to use technology to proudly disseminate their “conquests”.

I am not advocating banning of this book (or any book, for that matter).  I will actually continue to let Sparky read these books, because I want to encourage his love of reading and allow him to make choices about what he reads.  I also think these books provide “teachable moments” about technology that will eventually need to be addressed with Sparky, regardless of whether he had read these books.  But I do intend to discuss all of the content with him, and will try to nudge him as much as possible toward other books.  I have no problem saying to him and others, “I don’t like these books, and this is why.” Who knows, he might give up on the books just because he is tired of having these conversations with me…

Oh, and when the movie comes out, I can guarantee you that our family will not be seeing it, no matter what the rating.

Categories: cyberbullying | 4 Comments

Post navigation

4 thoughts on “I hate Captain Underpants

  1. Joseph

    Technology is a part of everything now, even bullying. I guess it’s just one more thing to add to the list, unfortunately. Hopefully there are enough positive messages to outweigh the negative ones put forth by Captain Underpants, et al., but sometimes you have to wonder if there are.

    • Karl

      I think the book reveals a reality – the reality of bullying. Kids understand this reality and are often times victimized by it. Most cases are left unseen. In the mind of kids, there is a hope for an alternate FICTIONAL reality where heroes can save them (ex. Captain Underpants or even George and Harold) and the power shifts to the weak instead.

      The book does NOT moralize and claim, “oh do this, fight back bullying through bullying”. It just states a reality through fiction. Good kids such as your own KNOW THE RIGHT thing. Other good kids who are bullied merely needs a release and an escape to fantasy. I do not believe the author, Dav Pilkey is starting a revolution of violence but rather created an acknowledgement that this books speaks the “bullied child” language and perspective. It does not speak like the “distant adult”. That it too wishes a fictional world of fairness. Wherein only in books such as these, the power play can shift.

      • Thanks for your thoughtful response. I think you do an excellent job of explaining the massive appeal of these books, but it is the effects that I am concerned about. For an interesting discussion of the escape through fantasy phenomenon, I suggest the book How Fantasy Becomes Reality by Karen Dill. I have no doubt that the author had good intentions. Hopefully, these books can be used to start conversations with children about topics relevant to them, such as bullying.

  2. John Verity

    My son, now 15, read many if not all of these books back in the day. He loved them. And I found them fairly witty and engaging, too, I must say. But I certainly do not recall ANY mention of computer screens and digital gizmos, and especially not the use of them for harassing people. I suppose the author – name? – has felt the need to bring his fictional world up to date, so to speak, which is too bad. (An even worser example of such fiddling crossed my computer-addled eyes years ago when we bought a decent-looking book of fairy tales. I opened the book to ‘Little Red Riding Hood’ only to find it describing grandma shopping on the Internet with her computer in bed. Aghast, we promptly tossed the book. What were they thinking?!)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com. The Adventure Journal Theme.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: